10. The Radio Dept., âCommitted To The Causeâ
These Swedes almost always appear blissfully out of timeâwhen first hearing âPulling Our Weightâ in Sofia Coppolaâs Marie Antoinette, I assumed it was from 1983, not 2003. So it goes with this unlikely swirl of early â90s Madchester dance-rock (with a smidge of Toto!), which lyrically at least remains the most timely and prescient tune of 2016.
9. Daft Punk feat. Julian Casablancas, âInstant Crushâ
An instant standout from Random Access Memories, not only for DPâs deepest dive into New Wave, but also for its robot-voiced utilization of The Strokesâ lead singer, of all people. Blame the melody or chord changes, but I have a far stronger emotional reaction to Casablancaâs voice when itâs masked like this. Shouldâve been the albumâs second single instead of âLose Yourself To Danceâ.
8. Twin Shadow, âToo Many Colorsâ
George Lewis Jr.âs 1980s-inspired project produced a great run of singles across this decade; my favorite is this track from 2018âs Caerâa soulful/electro combo that I never wouldâve thought feasible (at least outside of Alison Moyet.) Still, it all comes together beautifully, from its bell-like flourishes and unstoppable chorus to Lewisâ impassioned vocal.
7. Iron & Wine, âCall It Dreamingâ
After a series of ever-more lushly produced albums that bent his folk-pop as far as it could in that direction, Sam Beam returned to form with this straightforward but effective tune. Organically building from lone acoustic-guitar-and-vocal to a full-bodied arrangement, it ends up resounding like a beating heart that has gradually expanded until itâs all you can hear, and itâs everything.
6. Belle & Sebastian, âNobody’s Empireâ
At his peak, Stuart Murdoch sang, âNobody writes them like they used to / So it may as well be meâ; nearly two decades on, heâs still at it on a single as good as anything from If Youâre Feeling Sinister, only with the added musical prowess and wisdom gleaned from twenty years of struggle and exhilaration. The songâs gorgeous, chiming hook gives me hope that heâll keep writing âem well into this new decade and beyond.
5. Saint Etienne, âTonightâ
What a way to return after a seven-year hiatusâthe central song on an album about loving pop music, itâs an ideal three-minute encapsulation of this veteran trioâs inclusive approach and aesthetic. Early in their careers, the inimitable Sarah Cracknell and her mates invited listeners to âJoin Our Clubâ, but you see, theyâve always been fans as well: âI can hardly wait,â she sings, and her joy is just infectious.
4. Robyn, âDancing On My Ownâ
Considering that it never even made the Billboard Hot 100, Iâm thrilled to see this song popping up on so many end-of-decade lists. Regarding vulnerable yet defiant crying-on-the-dancefloor anthems, this is easily one of the all-time best for how the groove steamrolls along while also never obscuring the infinite shades of pain and perseverance in Robynâs bruised but luminous performance.
3. Jens Lekman, âEvening Prayerâ
Only Lekman would ever write a song about a man at a bar showing off a 3-D model of a tumor surgically removed from his back to his friend and a waitress; only he could make it both so jubilant and melancholy, inserting almost ridiculously bubbly âdoo-doo-dooâsâ within a blue-eyed soul arrangement. And thereâs something in the way he sings, âItâs been a long, hard yearâ that nearly destroys me every time I hear it.
2. Mavis Staples, âTry Harderâ
Sometimes, the simplest songs are the most effective: twelve-bar blues progression, guttural, insistent one-riff guitar, and a 78-year-old vocalist sounding nearly as robust as she did at half that age. With production support from improbable kindred spirit Jeff Tweedy, Staples is no oneâs idea of an old fogeyâespecially when she repeats the key lyric, âDonât do me no good to pretend / Iâm as good as I could be.â
1. Destroyer, âKaputtâ Kaputt the album cracked my top five of the decade, but it might not have without its monumental title-track centerpiece, which I knew was something extraordinary from my first listen nine years ago this month. You can liken Dan Bejarâs slight effervescence here to any number of signifiers (yacht rock, synth-pop, etc.), but in the end, âKaputtâ subsists in its very own universe, that incessant dit-dit-dit sequencer noise guiding an evocative quest through time and memory whose precise sound is an impeccable match for Bejarâs acquired-taste vocals. âAll sounds like a dream to meâ indeed.
Until recently, I was set on counting down my fifty favorite albums of this decade, as I did for the last one and the one before that. However, given that I’ve spent years writing extensively/exhaustively about favorite albums, including eleven from this past decade, I’m weary of saying much more on these long-players. So, in two weeks I will count down my fifty favorite tracks of the decade instead. I don’t buy into the death-of-the-album hysteria that began with digital downloads and seems to have swelled with online streaming, but I will argue that the technology often allows for a single or an album track to make a deeper, obviously more immediate impact than a thirty-to-seventy-minute-long collection of songs.
More about that in two weeks. I will never stop loving albums and ranking my favorites, but compared to the past two decades, nothing from the 2010s has hit me so powerfully as Automatic For The People, If You’re Feeling Sinister, Apartment Life, Since I Left You and Riot On An Empty Streetdid upon arrival. Of course, I first heard all those records in my 20s and it’s only natural that as I age, I should grow more critical and less susceptible towards the new, especially in how it relates to an already established artist’s body of work.
However, I still firmly believe in the possibility that my favorite album (or song) of all time might be something I haven’t yet heard. At the end of 2009, I knew nothing of Laura Marling, Nicole Atkins, Field Music, The Clientele or Future Islands, even though they all had records out. Then, there are the new talents that emerged and are represented below: Christine and The Queens, Natalie Prass, Michael Kiwanuka, Lana Del Rey, Haimâall of whom I suspect will continue releasing vital music in the next decade.
As for the list below, I struggled a bit with the order, for everything’s prone to change from month to year to day. Thus, I focused on albums I could see myself most wanting to listen to again and again, even after having already heard them dozens of times. Home Counties fulfills such criteria more strongly than anything else I could think ofâI’m not sure if it’s even Saint Etienne’s best or second-best (or even fifth-best) album, but its breadth and scope effortlessly draws me in; as a reaction to Brexit, it’s also one of the more timely albums here, certainly up there with Running Out of Love, Record and My Finest Work Yet as something that one could’ve only conceived of in the past three-to-four years.
Some surprises here and there: Edge of the Sun not making 100 Albums but placing so high as it became one of my most-listened-to records ever; Random Access Memories‘ stature in my mind slipping somewhat, as its retro-isms still delight but no longer innovate; a handful of records from the first half of the decade showing up, despite not making my half-decade list in 2015 (most notably Tales of Us, Transference and The Voyager); only three artists (Saint Etienne, Tracey Thorn and Hot Chip) appearing more than once, as opposed to Sam Phillips, who had three slots in the ’00s list.
In any case, at the end of this particular decade, here’s how I’d rank my favorite albums from it:
Saint Etienne, Home Counties
Emm Gryner, Northern Gospel
Calexico, Edge of the Sun
Jens Lekman, I Know What Love Isn’t
Destroyer, Kaputt
Tracey Thorn, Record
The Radio Dept., Running Out Of Love
Roisin Murphy, Hairless Toys
Andrew Bird, My Finest Work Yet
Marina and the Diamonds, Froot
Daft Punk, Random Access Memories
Laura Marling, I Speak Because I Can
Christine and The Queens, Christine and The Queens
Raphael Saadiq, Stone Rollin’
Nicole Atkins, Goodnight Rhonda Lee
Natalie Prass, The Future and The Past
Florence + The Machine, How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful
Holy Ghost!, Work
Hot Chip, One Life Stand
Field Music, Open Here
Tracey Thorn, Love and Its Opposite
Goldfrapp, Tales Of Us
The Clientele, Music For The Age Of Miracles
Robert Forster, Inferno
Michael Kiwanuka, Love & Hate
David Bowie, Blackstar
Saint Etienne, Words and Music By Saint Etienne
Janelle Monae, The ArchAndroid
Fiona Apple, The Idler Wheel…
Robyn, Body Talk
Imperial Teen, Now We Are Timeless
Sufjan Stevens, Carrie & Lowell
Lana Del Rey, Norman Fucking Rockwell!
Pet Shop Boys, Electric
Belle and Sebastian, Girls In Peacetime Want To Dance
(My 100 favorite albums in chronological order:Â #99Â â released June 2, 2017)
Track listing: The Reunion / Something New / Magpie Eyes / Whyteleafe / Dive / Church Pew Furniture Restorer / Take It All In / Popmaster / Underneath The Apple Tree / Out Of My Mind / After Hebden / Breakneck Hill / Heather / Sports Report / Train Drivers In Eyeliner / Â Unopened Fan Mail / What Kind Of World / Sweet Arcadia / Angel Of Woodhatch
After the superlative song cycle Tales From Turnpike House, I couldn’t imagine what Saint Etienne would do nextâapparently, neither could the band, at least not right away. Seven years passed before the release of their next album, Words and Music By Saint Etienne. Concerning the rituals and pleasures of pop music itself, the concept seemed ideal for a trio of self-avowed fans-turned-aspiring-popstars; in practice, it worked well enough, widely viewed as a comeback on both sides of the pond. It featured some of their very best singles (âTonightâ, âI’ve Got Your Musicâ) and, as usual with this group, exceptional album tracks that could’ve easily been singles as well (âHeading For The Fairâ, âLast Days Of Discoâ, âDJâ and the song this blog takes its name from.)
And yet… as a big fan myself, I found Words and Music not completely up to snuff with the four previous Saint Etienne albums I’ve covered here. For one thing, it has a substantial amount of, well, not filler, exactly, but lesser songs I rarely listen to in isolation (âAnswer Songâ, âTwenty Five Yearsâ, actual throwaway âRecord Doctorâ); also, celebrating pop through the prism of London is more or less what this trio has always done, but by making it so explicit and upfront, they almost lessen what’s so singular and special about it. Again, for any band, Words and Music is a good album and for them a shrewd one to make after such a long absence, but it doesn’t add anything new to their catalog in the way, say, Tiger Bay or even Good Humor did.
Fast forward a few more years: thereâs another band sabbatical during which Sarah Cracknell puts out a second solo album, Red Kite (solid singer-songwriter folk, and worlds away from the dance-pop of her earlier effort Lipslide) while Bob Stanley and Pete Wiggs continue curating compilations of subterranean gems from the 50âs, 60âs and 70âs. When the trio commence work on new material in mid-2016, the world in is flux. Brexit has passed and Trumpism clouds the air. Their new songs aren’t especially angry (how inconceivable to think of an incensed Saint Etienne!) but these developments (especially the hitting-closer-to-home Brexit) have no small impact on the direction their ninth album begins to take.
For most Americans and non-anglophiles, the title Home Counties requires some explanation. The two-word term refers to the seven counties surrounding Londonâin other words, the suburbs. All three members of Saint Etienne grew up there before moving to London as adults; it follows that one can view the record as reminiscent and hyper-specific of a time and place as Fox Base Alpha and So Tough were of early ’90s London, only observed from a great distance instead of documenting it in real time. However, the album transcends childhood nostalgia because of the band’s obvious love/hate relationship with the region, elevated in no small part by that recent specter of Brexit hanging in the airâthroughout the actual Home Counties, more people voted to leave the EU than remain, whereas London voted heavily in favor of the latter option.
The result is an intriguing push-and-pull for Saint Etienne: emphatic and celebratory as always, but now guided by hindsight and filtered through a sharper, critical eye. Initially, it resembles Good Humor more than anything else in the bandâs catalog thanks to its live-band feel (the winsome yet enigmatic âUnopened Fan Mailâ could easily slot into it) and the fact that Cracknellâs, Stanleyâs and Wiggsâ coming-of-age years coincide with the AM radio gold the earlier album successfully emulated. However, Home Counties is no Good Humor II: a mosaic of instrumentals, spoken word interludes and tone poems along with the expected three-minute pop songs, itâs the bandâs longest (19 tracks in 56 minutes, but they do fly by) and most varied album since Finisterre (maybe even So Tough)âit plays like a thoughtfully, lovingly compiled mix tape that coheres into a shimmering whole after multiple spins.
As youâd expect from a band known for their meticulous, often hand-crafted attention to detail, Home Counties has ultra-specific talismans woven throughout its fabric. It makes ample room for birdsong and a pastoral childrenâs choir (âChurch Pew Furniture Restorerâ), a spot-on Northern Soul simulation (âUnderneath The Apple Treeâ), a little harp and plenty of harpsichord (most prominently on âWhyteleafeâ and âTake It All Inâ), and not one or two but three recreations of vintage radio transmissions, with quiz show âPopmasterâ rather tongue-in-cheek in offering such decidedly modern prizes as âa digital radio or a blue-tooth speaker.â For a band whose early albums were liberally sprinkled with sound bites from classic films, this reprises a tradition of dropping references that will go over a majority of listenersâ heads but also lend much distinction and texture to the world depicted within.
Throughout, Saint Etienne canât help but retain a certain fondness for where theyâre from. In one song, Cracknell eagerly encourages us to âTake It All Inâ over a baroque retro-pop arrangement with a vaguely trip-hop beat, resembling a rather unlikely cross between The Association and Portishead. âDiveâ is a memory of the kind of sensual, horn-driven funk workout one could get down to at the local disco or at a backyard, tiki torch-lit house party. With its clarion chorus and propulsive beat, âMagpie Eyesâ encapsulates the bittersweet feeling of being young in a small town after summerâs gone with nothing to do but seek hidden treasure among what remains. Along those lines, âOut Of My Mindâ further evokes both the euphoria and turmoil of adolescent infatuation, its ebullience and urgency rendering it a proud successor to such past triumphs as âNothing Can Stop Usâ and âLightning Strikes Twiceâ.
Still, they just as often firmly (if considerately) resist suburbia as the utopian ideal. âWhyteleafeâ may imagine an alternate universe where David Bowie never left home for London, settling into an ordinary life as a local businessman (Cracknell singing, âHis sweet mu-ni-ci-pal dreamâ over a surging synth is one of the albumâs most indelible hooks), but itâs merely a clever âwhat-ifâ scenario (and, a year after his death, a refreshingly unconventional Bowie tribute.) Meanwhile, the protagonist of âSomething Newâ is desperately searching for âa sound that she knows could be funâ, and the song’s electric 12-string guitar and Mellotron-aping synth lends her support, especially as it gives way to the resolve and warmth of a brass coda. âTrain Drivers In Eyelinerâ sweetly advocates for more flamboyantly attired, Whitesnake-listening conductors in an attempt to gently shake up the status quo: âAll over this land, thatâs our plan,â Cracknell coos, as if stumping for the idea at a Town Hall meeting.
As Home Counties proceeds, it further scrutinizes suburbia, putting aside any notion of rose-colored lenses. Its primary hues purposely turn darker beginning with âBreakneck Hillâ, a gorgeously drowsy instrumental that sounds straight out of Twin Peaks. Its spooky female sighs and Eno-esque ambient drone set the scene for âHeatherâ: a Hitchcock film in miniature, it recalls a neighbor or a childhood friend. Maybe sheâs a ghost now, for âShe comes and she goes like the warmth in the daylight.â Near the end, Cracknell repeats, âThis house is hauntedâ as the sputtering but insistent rhythm and minor key synths swirl around her, almost fortifying her claim. Perhaps, this taleâs ghost is the narrator herself, wrestling with her past and present selves.
A few tracks later, laden with sweeping, urgent strings, âWhat Kind of Worldâ fully acknowledges this identity crisis in relation to its milieu. âThis is my home but I donât feel at home tonight,â Cracknell declares before suggesting, âLetâs find another country / a better one,â and it has a thunderboltâs impactâfor many, the suburbs are a place to escape from due to their isolationism, conservatism and provincialism; Brexit enables the suburbs to uphold these tenets, legally cordoning off the outside world. Itâs an easy explanation as to main reason why the members of Saint Etienne left the Home Counties, but it doesnât necessarily shed light on why some people stay.
âSweet Arcadiaâ makes an effort to elucidate on this. Opening with another talisman, a watery electric piano of the kind heard on such â70s hits as âIâm Not In Loveâ and âJust The Way You Areâ, itâs another Cracknell spoken word piece in the tradition of âTeenage Winterâ and âOver The Borderâ: âThe trains took us away from the smoke,â she begins, narrating a travelogue through obscure, self-contained locales with names like Benfleet and South-End-On-Sea. A fetching, suitably locomotive rhythm moves us along as she recounts how the modern suburbs came to be. Over aching chord changes, she recites, âWe built our own cinemas, we named our own houses,â charting the ever-forward march of progress until she concludes, âWe took your land, and made it our land. Sweet Arcadia.â Her narration disappears halfway through this nearly eight-minute-long epic, consumed by extended flute and soulful organ solos as the beat slows to a wavering ebb-and-flow as if hovering on water.
After Cracknell mournfully sighs the songâs title repeatedly at the close, weâre left not with a resolution but unease. Saint Etienne have offered us plenty of reasons to both love and loathe suburbia; such a mass of contradictory feelings is more true to life than art that would either merely bask in the glow of its idyllic landscapes or only reveal them to be nothing but a cultural wasteland. And as much as this trio has forged a career on songs about transcendence and escape, Home Counties is a step in another direction, observing the world not just as it could be, but also as it is.
And why canât we consider both simultaneously? If the penultimate âSweet Arcadiaâ is to Home Counties what âHello Earthâ was to Kate Bushâs Hounds of Love, closing track âAngel of Woodhatchâ is this albumâs equivalent to âThe Morning Fogâ. Its gentle woodwinds and sparkling wind chimes potentially suggest promise and renewal; here, with no lyrics to guide us toward a particular opinion, they could simply infer calm and stillnessâa sweet surrender to a complex world with so many moving parts. Home Counties is Saint Etienneâs âmatureâ album for sure, but its richness and teeming ambiguities gives that off-derided term a good name.
(My 100 favorite albums in chronological order:Â #83 â released June 13, 2005)
Track listing:Â Sun In My Morning / Milk Bottle Symphony / Lightning Strikes Twice / Slow Down At The Castle / A Good Thing / Side Streets / Last Orders For Gary Stead / Stars Above Us / Relocate / The Birdman of EC1 / Teenage Winter / Goodnight
To paraphrase a classic title of one by Rod Stewart, every album tells a story: it could revolve around hastily assembled contractual obligation or inspired artistic reinvention, announce a new talent to the world or remind a long-uninterested audience what that talent is still capable of. Occasionally, it can even tell a literal storyâa concept album, if you will. I’ve written about a few on this blog, from a concise suite about sexual infatuation to a conflation of the cycle of life with the four seasons. Some are predominantly defined by structure or sequencing; there’s also a number that forgo linear narratives for sustained themes such as childhood and parenting, impending mortality or a failed love affair (perhaps the most popular album concept of all.)
None of the three discs I’ve previously covered by British pop trio Saint Etienne were strict concept albums, but they each told at the very least figurative stories. So Tough (1993) served as a collage of early ’90s London sights and sounds, Tiger Bay (1994) combined electronic dance and acoustic folk into a shimmering whole and Good Humor (1998) recreated the 1970s AM radio gold its members Bob Stanley, Pete Wiggs and Sarah Cracknell grew up with. Their subsequent albums would also hinge upon a common aesthetic or theme: Sound of Water (2000) mostly eschewed the band’s typical pop hooks for atmosphere and texture, while Finisterre (2002) set out to capture London at the crossroads of a new century, linking together a dozen aurally disparate tracks with Michael Jayston’s authoritative spoken word narration. Neither album was necessarily subpar, but something about them felt less immediate and a little tentative, as if in a quest to continually explore new avenues, the band lost some of the luster that those three prior albums emanated effortlessly.
Fortunately, their next record, Tales From Turnpike House pushes their sound to new heights, but with none of that hesitationâit’s assured and complete as anything they’ve ever done. Not coincidentally, it’s their first album to sport an overarching narrative: a day in the life of various residents of a London tower block (for non-Brits, roughly, a high-rise apartment building.) It’s such an ideal concept for this particular band, whose back catalog’s not only undeniably London-centric but also steeped in humanism with a rare ability to find exceptional beauty in day-to-day life. Building upon such a strong, likeminded focal point brings out the best in them as lyricists.
However, Tales is even more special for the distinct backing vocals and harmonies on nearly all of the album’s songs, which were arranged and performed by Tony Rivers and his son, Anthony. It’s typical Saint Etienne for their members to reach out to a relatively obscure and forgotten-by-the-public-at-large figure like Rivers, a former member of late ’60s sunshine pop group Harmony Grass and a ’70s and ’80s session background vocalist. And yet, the familial, choirboy harmonies by him and his son are arguably the album’s secret weapon. On first listen, they seem more than a little retro and heavily reminiscent of The Beach Boys (a fitting touchstone, since St. Et. swiped the titles So Tough and Good Humor from them.) Over the course of an album, they become a wordless Greek chorus, musically binding everything together, their omnipresence gradually more resonant and profound.
âSun In My Morningâ opens Tales with a quiet but insistent ting-ting-ting percussive soundâpossibly a triangle or a chime. Here, it acts as sort of an alarm clock, only softer and kinder (this is a decidedly slow, sweet wake-up call.) Over an acoustic guitar, Cracknellâs inimitable vocal follows, elongating words and phrases to their breaking point: âMade⊠a list of things to do⊠today / what a shame⊠the morning breeze just blew⊠it all away.â Then, just over thirty seconds in, the songâs title announces the chorus. On that chord change, everything brilliantly comes alive: some soulful organ, a skittering flute, and most prominently, the Riversâ intricate, overlapping harmonies.
Having had ample time to wipe the sleep from our eyes, âMilk Bottle Symphonyâ vaults forward, upping the tempo and introducing us to various Turnpike House residentsâamong them, âNumber twelve, thereâs Amy Chan / Writing down a line for the candy man,â and âEmily Roeâs at Thirty-One / Twenty minutes left to get her homework done.â Gifted as the band is at pinpointing such minute details (Emily âleaves her cornflakes on the sofa / says goodbye to mumâ), they also excel at painting a bigger picture: note the dramatic pause at mid-song, silence ceased by a sweet clang-clang-clang that could be a literal interpretation of the songâs title, or how effective the staccato string section sounds over the trackâs driving electronic beat on the instrumental coda.
âLightning Strikes Twiceâ is the first of many Tales tracks where Saint Etienne reclaim their status as purveyors of alternate-world number-one hits. Resembling a more earnest, if no less slinky version of synth-pop duo Goldfrapp, the song kicks off with Cracknell in her lowest register, modulating her vocal up a few notches with each line until it reaches the euphoric chorus of âEveryone should have a reason to believe / so I still believe that / lightning will strike twice for me,â dramatically stretching out that first word to âEvvv â ryyyy â one.â An irresistible paean to sustained optimism as a life-force, âLightning Strikes Twiceâ goes out on a limitless high, reprising the songâs key-changing middle-eight with the Riversâ harmonies guiding all into the stratosphere.
The contrast between it and âSlow Down At The Castleâ could not be more striking: after a mournful folk guitar intro, it shifts into a minor-key suburban gothic thatâs almost a warmer, kinder cousin to So Toughâs similarly-toned epic âAvenueâ. Its childlike melody gels splendidly with Cracknellâs phrasing but its complexity comes from a few rather baroque but well-employed touches: a harpsichord break, impossibly lovely backing âbong-bong-bongâ Rivers harmonies, even a surprise Theremin solo! The piano melody on the outro mirrors the guitar intro almost identically, adding an exquisite grace note at the end.
âA Good Thingâ brings Saint Etienne back to masterful dance pop mode with a vengeance. This albumâs second single and a close cousin to their biggest UK hit âHeâs On The Phoneâ, it dutifully sounds ultra-contemporary, downplaying the idiosyncrasies of Talesâ preceding songs (almost nary a Rivers to be heard here.) Happily, even at their most accessible, Bob, Pete and Sarah rarely settle for anonymity. As in many a St. Et. composition, Cracknell remains pragmatic but urgent, droll but serious in advising and furthermore reminding a former lover just whatâs he lost. Still, what sounds gloomy on the page is transformed by the musicâs continual uplift, so much that Pedro Almodovar, a fan, placed the song in his film Volver and it fit beautifully without receding into the background.
An endearingly fragile bossa-nova practically gliding by on vibes, bongos, spare electro-beats and a whole lot of âba, ba, baâsâ from Cracknell and the Rivers, âSide Streetsâ was an unconventional choice for the albumâs first single, if only for all the surefire big pop productions surrounding it. The lyrics, about a single woman on her daily commute are also far more complex than your average top 40 fluff. Cracknell sings of taking the long way home, acknowledging but not altogether fearful about dangers lurking within an urban centerâs corners. Sheâs at once defiant (âI’ve got features I quite like and don’t mind keepingâ) and matter-of-fact (âIâll probably get it tomorrowâ) but the warmth of the arrangement and her vocal (try not to melt at the way she pronounces the word âbubbleâ) tempers what in less nuanced hands could come off as merely chilling.
After a somewhat deceptive, slow piano intro, âLast Orders For Gary Steadâ suddenly locks into a two-chord glam rock groove, complete with electric guitar, pounding piano and Cracknell sounding like the love child of David Bowie and Dusty Springfield. The first St. Et. Tune that absolutely swaggers, it should be an anomalous fit but it works, especially when it reaches its heavenly, Rivers-assisted multi-tracked chorus. Having briefly met the title figure back in âMilk Bottle Symphonyâ, Gary serves as a through line for the albumâs overarching narrative. Here, heâs at his preferred environment of the local pub, and a figure of amusement to some (listen to how tartly Cracknell sings, âHe just cools it down / they should knight him for it.â) Still, heâs potentially a tragic figure as well. âSheâs in two minds, maybe sheâll board up her door,â the chorus explains, before resolving itself in a neat bit of wordplay: âHe sinks two pints / and thatâs how it goes.â
As the bandâs dance anthems go, âStars Above Usâ not only bests âA Good Thingâ but on some days might even top âHeâs On The Phoneâ. âStars above us, cars below us / Out on the rooftop, baby,â is its glorious chorus, riding high on a shamelessly disco groove (nearly nicked from Kylie Minogueâs âLove At First Sightâ) and Niles Rodgers-like rhythm guitar. Musically, itâs far from their most forward-looking song, but none of that matters when the beat kicks in after that dreamy intro and the chorus comes on full force. âStars Above Usâ is positively transformative, taking one to the best place imaginable; in a nod to their greatest early single, Cracknell sings, âNothing can touch us, baby,â and itâs awfully hard to disagree with her.
Amazingly, âStars Above Usâ was not a UK single, but Savoy Jazz, Saint Etienneâs then-US record label had the foresight to promote the song and a series of remixesâit became the bandâs first top ten club play hit in over a decade. Unfortunately, the label ended up seriously botching Talesâ US release seven months after the original edition came out: not only did they rearrange the track listing, placing the two UK singles at the beginning and thus doing away with the day-in-the-life-of-a-tower-block chronology, they cut out the two tracks following âStars Above Usâ and inserted two new replacements (âDream Loverâ, âOh Myâ) randomly into the albumâs sequence.
Granted, the two nixed tracks are arguably Talesâ least essential. âRelocateâ, a duet between Cracknell and David Essex (sounding far more weathered here than on his â70s hits like âRock Onâ) reads like a distaff Brit take on the old Green Acres theme (wife wants to move to the country, husband wants to stay put in the city.) Itâs charming (love the pointed, irritated way she asks him, âYou call this life?â) and fits in with the overall concept, but itâs also slight, its merry-go-round melody a touch too music hall for these sophisticates. Meanwhile, âThe Birdman of EC1â, the albumâs sole instrumental, is a melancholy organ, mandolin and Mellotron-accented breath of fresh air and little else. However, Tales needs both songs for they provide necessary texture; without them (as on the US edition), the transition from âStars Above Usâ to the albumâs two final crucial songs feels jarring and rushed.
Tales enters its most powerful stretch with the startling fanfare of harmonies and chiming notes that announces âTeenage Winterâ, one of the most unabashedly heartbreaking songs in a catalog with no shortage of them. In its verses, Cracknell delivers a spoken word monologue, reuniting us with such figures as Gary Stead and other various building residents. If âMilk Bottle Symphonyâ depicted them with an air of promise and hope, now theyâre more wistful, almost melancholic, really. Their world is continually in flux: a chain tanning salon replaces a mom-and-pop bakery, and the internet’s daunting presence lessens the nifty stock for record collectors scouring the local thrift shop. Each person is inevitably getting older, âholding on to something / without knowing / exactly what youâre looking for.â Over melodic triplet notes resembling softly falling snow, Cracknell sings in the chorus:
Teenage Winterâs coming down Teenage Winter floats a gown Over every place Iâve been And every little dream Forever.
That last word just hangs there, gorgeously resounding through the songâs lush guitar, organ and woodwind arrangement (which also includes a sneakily affecting melodic bassline.) âTeenage Winterâ is an incredibly poignant lament, made even more so by the fact that Bob and Pete had just entered their 40s when they recorded it (with Sarah not too far off)âfor the first time, one can detect a real sense of mortality in Saint Etienneâs world. Rather than rally at timeâs arrow with nostalgia and self-pity, they confront it the kindness, wisdom and acceptance that only comes with age.
It seems inconceivable that anything could top âTeenage Winterâ, but closing track âGoodnightâ comes perilously close. A simple lullaby, it brings Tales full circle from âSun In My Morningâ. Stripping away all instrumentation, weâre left with Sarah, Tony and Anthony. Hearing just these voices at this point in the albumâs sequence and the extraordinarily haunting sound they make together (like a delicate tapestry of onomatopoeia) is almost too much to bear. So is Sarah pleading, âPlease sing me to sleep and stroke my hair / Iâll close my eyes and pretend that youâre there.â That little couplet really gets at what Tales as a whole is all about: one can always uncover specks of brilliance in everyday, ordinary things, but real transcendence often comes in dreams, in imagining possibilities and processing pain, and using this learned experience to move forward. These threads run deep through Saint Etienneâs entire oeuvre, but on Tales they push furthest, expressed so eloquently theyâre impossible to miss or shake.
In a cruel twist of fate, Tales ended up the bandâs worst selling album to date in the UK (as with what happened to Tiger Bay, the botched US version didnât help matters much.) Perhaps âStars Above Usâ or even âLightning Strikes Twiceâ shouldâve been the lead single, or maybe, just maybe, Tales was so ambitiously out-of-time with what constituted a hit in 2005. One could argue thatâs always been the case with this cult-adored trio; for me, Tales had a larger impact than anything else I heard that year (possibly that entire decade.) It was like Iâd been wishing, hoping, waiting for one of my favorite bands to create their masterpiece (despite them already having put out at least three great albums.) And then, they did. Whatâs more, while Tales was originally to be their final appearance in 100 Albums, as of this writing, Iâm confident thatâs no longer the case.
3. St. Vincent, “MASSeduction”
âOne of our great female eccentrics,â I wrote about Annie Clark on her last albumâa handle she still maintains, even if it now feels like a reduction. She promised a game-changer of a fifth album, and she makes good on that claim, though not in the way I expected, which is of course exactly why she clinches it. More accessible and outgoing, yes, but also just as arch and in control, MASSeduction (only she could get away with that title) features a seven-song sequence (from âPillsâ to âNew Yorkâ) as breathless as anything I’ve heard, a Prince pastiche that nearly outdoes him (the title track), an euphoric rush of a sexual conquest where she nearly outdoes herself (âSugarboyâ) and a bold closer (âSmoking Sectionâ) that suggests she’s far from done pushing her own artistic boundaries.
“MASSeduction”:
2. Nicole Atkins, “Goodnight Rhonda Lee”
Previously, Atkins struck me as an incredible, tremulous singer in search of a voice, capable of an occasional great song (âMaybe Tonightâ, âGirl You Look Amazingâ) but nothing more. Oh, how her fourth album proves me wrongâdeliberately, unfashionably out-of-time, it successfully repositions her as a genre-inclusive torch songstress as likely to co-write retro-rock laments with Chris Isaak (âA Little Crazyâ, the title track) as she is to evoke the likes of Dusty In Memphis (âDarkness Falls So Quietâ) and Make Way For Dionne Warwick (âIf I Couldâ). What’s more, Goodnight Rhonda Lee smoothly sprints from high to high, its eleven songs all of a piece. Still, I would be remiss not to single out âI Love Living Here (Even When I Don’t)â, a smart, ultimately devastating expression of how miserable and simultaneously content one can feel.
“I Love Living Here (Even When I Don’t):
1. Saint Etienne, “Home Counties”
At 19 tracks in just under an hour, it’s their longest long player; also their most musically diverse since Finisterre (if not So Tough.) Citing Brexit as a jumping-off point, Bob, Pete and Sarah present a concept album about the London suburbs they grew up in and continue to have a love/hate relationship with. Even more deeply felt than the pop-timism of 2012’s Words and Music, this one instantly locates that sweet spot the band’s always depended on, finding great inspiration in the mundane. Proceeding from typically immaculate three-minute singles (âMagpie Eyesâ, âOut of My Mindâ) and AM radio gold (âUnderneath the Apple Treeâ, âTake It All Inâ) to moodier stuff like instrumental âBreakneck Hillâ and the beguiling, ominous âHeatherâ, all its disparate parts eventually form a gestalt, culminating in âSweet Arcadiaâ: another in a series of Saint Etienne epics going back to âAvenueâ, it evokes this world in exquisite detail via time, memory and such talismans as its gorgeous, watery electric piano straight out of 10cc’s âI’m Not In Loveâ. Home Counties is easily my record of the year, and one of this venerable trio’s very best.
Say what you want about 2017 being shit so far, âcause it decidedly is not where music’s concerned (or TV, for that matterâconsider Twin Peaks, Legion and The Americans, just for starters.) In the unlikely event that I come across no other good new albums between now and December, the ones listed below from the yearâs first half would make for a pretty darn tootinâ top ten.
Of course, some gurls are better than others. I admire Stephin Merrittâs quintuple-LP opus more than I ever get around to playing the damn thing, and while the Mann record is easily her best since Bachelor # 2, I have to be in a certain mood for it. Iâm genuinely surprised at how much I enjoy Goths (perhaps because itâs far more Donald Fagen than Robert Smith?) and Hot Thoughts, although I shouldnât be because I tend to love exactly every other Spoon LP for some reason (see: Transference, Gimme Fiction and Girls Can Tell.)
Predictably, the Saint Etienne is my favorite so far. Even though Iâve had less than a month to live with their growing-up-in-suburban-London opus Home Counties, my god, what a month⊠Not only is it already better than the very good Words and Music, Iâm thinking this might end up… their best yet? Will this ultimately ring true or will I eventually burn out on it? Check back in six monthsâin the meantime, enjoy the sublime âOut of My Mindâ, which at the very least deserves more than only 300+ YouTube views.
My favorite 2017 albums so far, in alphabetical order:
Aimee Mann, Mental Illness Alison Moyet, Other Future Islands, The Far Field Goldfrapp, Silver Eye Jens Lekman, Life Will See You Now Laura Marling, Semper Femina The Magnetic Fields, 50 Song Memoir The Mountain Goats, Goths Saint Etienne, Home Counties Spoon, Hot Thoughts
(My 100 favorite albums in chronological order:Â #60Â â released September 8, 1998)
Track listing: Woodcabin / Sylvie / Split Screen / Mr. Donut / Goodnight Jack / Lose That Girl / The Bad Photographer / Been So Long / Postman / Erica America / Dutch TV / Hill Street Connection / Hit the Brakes / Madeleine / Swim Swam Swim / 4:35 In The Morning / Clark County Record Fair / Zipcode / My Name Is Vlaovic / Afraid to Go Home / La La La / Cat Nap
After putting out three studio albums in as many years, another four would pass before Saint Etienne finally released their next one. That’s not to say they were entirely inactive during this sabbatical; they did release numerous compilations including a greatest hits album (which featured âHeâs On The Phoneâ, their recent one-off, highest-charting UK single), a Japanese-only odds-and-sods collection and a pretty great solo effort from vocalist Sarah Cracknell (even more tracks from this period eventually surfaced on various fan club-only releases.)
One doesn’t necessarily have to hear the bulk of this output in order to understand how the band redefined its sound between Tiger Bay and Good Humor (for the most part, it’s not readily available to download or stream, particularly in the US), although for fans, it fills in the gaps between the former’s cinematic, genre-bending soundscapes and the latter’s more refined approach. Better to view the relatively stripped-down Good Humor as a back-to-basics record, a homage to the late ’60s/early ’70s AM radio pop group members Bob Stanley, Pete Wiggs and Cracknell cut their teeth on. With producer Tore Johansson, best known for his work for Swedish lounge-poppers The Cardigans, Saint Etienne made an album not too far away from the likes of âLovefoolâ, that other group’s big hit from the previous year.
Good Humor generally opts for a live band sound, which stands in direct contrast to their past studio-centric output. Opener âWoodcabinâ eases into this style with an isolated, mechanical-like rhythm that may or may not be a drum machine. Then, a funk bassline kicks in, followed by jazzy Fender Rhodes electric piano, acoustic guitar and muted trumpet filigrees. However, it no longer resembles a Cardigans song once Cracknell’s inimitable vocals appear. She elongates syllables to their breaking points on the verses (rendering âA beauty queen from Idaho,â as âa beauuu-tee queeeen (pause) from Iiii-da-hoeâ) before arriving at the chilled-out chorus: âNever write a ballad / got to get a grip now / cause nothing ever matters / if you hide away from it all.â That last phrase, along with the overall laid-back vibe, places them in a far cozier setting than ever before.
The album’s lead single âSylvieâ promptly returns them to the dancefloor. An ABBA-worthy Eurodisco anthem, it falls comfortably in line with such past uptempo hits as âJoin Our Clubâ and âPale Movieâ and yet, it’s different. None of those past hits, for instance, had a minute-plus long instrumental intro, with nearly thirty seconds of solo piano previewing the song’s entire melody before being replaced by frenetic congas. The piano then shifts to an enticing samba-like rhythm, and the drum machines and synths soon kick in. When Cracknell’s vocals finally appear, you’re immersed in such a peculiar way that you feel you know the song, but that there’s also more yet to be revealed.
Cracknell sings to the titular woman who has just stolen her man, âSylvie, girl, Iâm a very patient person / but I’ll have to shut you down / if you don’t give up your flirting.â She follows this with one of the song’s many hooks, the taunting but knowing âYou know he’s mine, you know he’s mine.â It’s not until the final verse that she reveals Sylvie is no mere schoolyard rival, but rather poignantly her own little sister. âGive it all up ’cause I know you’ve been trying / over and over and over and over again,â she sings, blissfully repeating those last words unto infinity as the song swells and sighs. I remember either Stanley or Wiggs once called âSylvieâ a ’90s update of Yvonne Elliman’s Saturday Night Fever chestnut âIf I Can’t Have Youâ; I can’t think of a more apt comparison.
Although Good Humor is unfathomable without âSylvieâ, it’s an outlier here; âSplit Screenâ is more what the album’s about. Coming off like an upbeat, ultra-groovy ’70s sitcom theme, complete with horns and shimmering vibes, the song sounds tailor-made for swanky cocktail parties and suburban backyard picnics, but it’s no background musicânot with Cracknell breaking free from a staid relationship, singing with glee on the breathtaking, key-changing bridge, âNow I really don’t care / ’cause I’m dying to get the sun in my hair.â
While on their earlier records the contrast between her vocals and the mashed-up soundscapes enveloping them was a key part of the band’s appeal, Good Humorâs more organic arrangements fit Cracknell like a hand-knit glove. On âLose That Girlâ (musically a very close cousin to Rumors-era Christine McVie), she’s delectably catty, picking apart a friend’s recent ex-lover with savage but fair precision (âShe thought she’d look good in purple jeans from Santa Feâ, she observes), making perhaps the most damning accusation one could in the world of Saint Etienne: âOn her radio, she turned the disco down.â (!) Conversely, she’s just as convincingly wistful on âBeen So Longâ and melancholy on the gorgeously downbeat âPostmanâ, where her âba, ba, ba’sâ speak as much about her emotional well-being as lyrics such as, âI was only lonely / only thinking of you.â
Much of Good Humor plays like an extended K-Tel compilation of some of the band’s greatest and not necessarily hippest influences. With its luxuriant Barry White wah-wah guitar hook and hypnotic hi-hats, âErica Americaâ would fit right at home on a Soul Train couples dance segment. âBeen So Longâ is as well-constructed as Radio City-era Big Star and as winsome as The Carpenters (although a tad less syrupy) to almost resemble contemporaries Belle and Sebastian. âDutch TVâ lovingly emulates Vince Guaraldiâs Charlie Brown music (although no Peanuts special would ever include the lyric, âTurn the TV down, kick the TV in.â) In addition to being a perfect snapshot of an indie British band on tour in the USA, âMr. Donutâ is a blatant late-Beatles pastiche, all âStrawberry Fields Foreverâ-esque Mellotron and âYour Mother Should Knowâ-like fat fingers piano. Still, not even McCartney could come up with lyrics as endearingly daft as the song’s opening lines: âChecked into the airport half an hour late / Jackie caused a scene when we reached the gate / Sorry, Mr. Pilot, but you’ll have to wait / cause Paul’s still in the duty-free.â
Although the bandâs most approachable record to date, itâs also occasionally as adventurous as their past efforts. Itâs not hard to see why âThe Bad Photographerâ was picked as the albumâs second singleâfrom how it opens with an instrumental version of its bridge to the indelible âAll for youâ vocal hook in the chorus, itâs instantly hummable. The lyrics, on the other hand, are Saint Etienne at their most fascinatingly inscrutable, detailing a photo shoot and its aftermath, but observing it both in the first-person and at a distance. âSome secret / must keep it /hey, I wouldnât know who to tell,â goes one verse; later, Cracknell sings, âDays later / saw the paper / how did I fall for you?â Some vital information is left out between that gap (perhaps the secret?) and half the fun is trying to figure it out (while the other half is finding yourself singing along with her every word.)
âGoodnight Jackâ could almost have fit in on Tiger Bay with its striking intro of cascading lone guitar notes eventually subsumed by an almost symphonic backing slowly building in volume. Although the lyrics are somewhat more lucid than those on âThe Bad Photographerâ (âCan I take this once again / You know Iâd like to be a friend,â), the structure is anything but. After a few verses, the song shifts into an extended coda spiced with flutes and faux-harpsichord and Cracknell singing âSheâs got to run / run away from home,â over and over again. For all of Good Humorâs tendency towards three-minute potential radio hits, it doesnât completely obscure the leftfield experiments and studio-as-playground logic of their back catalog.
Regardless, Good Humor was enough of a departure that a chunk of the bandâs UK fanbase was left cold by what was a warmer and, to many ears, more American-sounding album. Accordingly, it managed the none-too-grave task of reestablishing Saint Etienne in the US, where it likely remains their best-selling release. While their first three albums came out here on Capitol (who botched Tiger Bayâs release with an alternate tracklisting and poor promotion), this one was released by Sub Pop, the famous indie label home at one time to Nirvana, Sonic Youth and The Shins. The mere idea of this very British pop trio being signed to a label heavily associated with grunge and alt-rock is a bit droll, but Sub Popâs boutique size and independent ethos was far closer in spirit to their likeminded British label, Creation.
Still, Good Humorâs eleven songs only tell part of the albumâs story in the US. Having arrived a few months after the UK release, the first 10,000 copies on Sub Pop came with a bonus disc, Fairfax High, which collected eleven more tracks, mostly B-sides from the âSylvieâ and âThe Bad Photographerâ UK singles. While very few would argue they comprise as sturdy a selection as whatâs on the main album, itâs strong enough to suggest that, perhaps, given a little more fine-tuning, Good Humor could have very well ended up a decent double album.
While nothing on Fairfax High comes close to the effervescent rush of âSylvieâ, thatâs okay. Apart from isolated uptempo numbers like âZipcodeâ and âHit the Brakesâ, this is more music to put on after coming home from the party. Two of the best songs are acoustic ballads one could reasonably describe as twee: âMadeleineâ has one of the prettiest melodies of any Saint Etienne song, with Cracknell backed by little more than acoustic piano and guitar, while the disarming âClark County Record Fairâ is the sort of love song only two record-collecting nerds like Stanley and Wiggs would ever write. Surely good enough to have fit on Good Humor, the gentle trip-hop of â4:35 In The Morningâ was probably relegated here due to its evocative title; âLa La Laâ doesnât reach quite such heights (as one can surmise by its title) although itâs not much lesser than Ivyâs comparable âBa Ba Baâ.
If anything, Fairfax High was instrumental in encouraging me to appreciate, well, instrumentals, of which it has four. Opener âHill Street Connectionâ (named for its brief interpolation of Mike Postâs Hill Street Blues theme) mists over you like a lush, refreshing summer rain; closer âCat Napâ, heavily reminiscent of the â60s instrumental piano hit âLast Dateâ has the opposite effect, gently, agreeably lulling one to sleep. âSwim Swam Swimâ floats on by with irresistible ease on a raft of piano chords, flutes, âba, ba, baâsâ and a simple shuffling rhythm; âMy Name is Vlaovicâ similarly lopes along a repeated, circular melody, only with an air of intrigue straight out of a â60s spy film. They all work as background music (or even Muzak, if you prefer) and yet the craft and attention to detail in each one enables the listener to curiously remain absorbedâa trick the band might have learned from Brian Eno.
Good Humor is one of those records that registered with me instantly (that I had just discovered the band the previous year and anticipated it madly certainly helped), but it didnât take long for me to love Fairfax High as well. For a time, this combo was my favorite Saint Etienne album. It remains in my top five of their voluminous catalog and is a solid entry point for newcomers to the band; if it lacks the ambition and forever-pushing-forward momentum of the bandâs greatest works (So Tough, Tiger Bay, and one other album to come in this project), itâs no less delightful a listen. Make yourself a cup of ginger tea, curl up on a comfortable seat, and enjoy.
(My 100 favorite albums in chronological order:Â #41Â â released February 28, 1994)
Track listing: Urban Clearway / Former Lover / Hug My Soul / Like A Motorway / On The Shore / Marble Lions / Pale Movie / Cool Kids of Death / Western Wind – Tankerville / The Boy Scouts of America
Then, at 1:16, it curves left as a cornucopia of real strings, woodwinds and harp glissandos all make nice on top of the synthesizersâthe songâs heretofore monochrome world has just opened up considerably, now resembling a exuberant version of an imagined late â70s action/adventure TV theme (Charlieâs Angels? Hart To Hart?). Perhaps âUrban Clearwayâ is, at its core, opening credits music for this, the most cinematic of all Saint Etienne albumsâit even shares its title with a 1959 Hayley Mills film. But then, the song curves left again, from major to minor key in the final minute. What kind of movie is this? Certainly not a fluffy comedy. Perhaps a kitchen sink drama? Maybe even an epic?
After the adrenaline rush of âUrban Clearwayâ comes its almost polar opposite: a hushed folk song. âFormer Loverâ begins with four strummed Spanish guitar chords, each of them slowly plucked so one can hear every single note they contain. Then, the guitar plays a rapid succession of five-note arpeggios over which we hear a sighing harmonica and pining vocalist Sarah Cracknell, who provides the melody via lyrics doled out in simple, Zen-like phrases (âMilan, when I was a kittenâ, âClose all of the doors, Maisieâ). The transition from the first track to the next nearly induces whiplash, but âFormer Loverâ is secretly the yang to the previous songâs yin.
Throughout their first three albums, Saint Etienne seemingly pride themselves on what startling juxtaposes they can come up with between (and often within) songs; a majority of Tiger Bay plays like proto folk-tronica, like an imagined collaboration between such disparate souls as Fairport Convention and Gary Numan. However, itâs still pop music and by itself, âFormer Loverâ is striking in both its somberness and melodicism and for the cozy melancholy it instantly conjures: curling up in a comfy chair, staring out a window, rain gently falling, its narrator delicately, arrestingly lost in thought and reverie.
Tiger Bayâs next two songs were also among its three singles. âHug My Soulâ sports even lusher orchestration than âUrban Clearwayâ, especially in its opening string fanfare. But Saint Etienne are still primarily an indie dance band (Wikipediaâs catch-all phrase for them) at this point in their career, and the songâs disco beat defines it. Faintly reminiscent of the old Andrea True Connection hit âMore, More, Moreâ, it pursues the same end (sex, natch) but via a kinder, gentler, but no less lustful means. By stretching out each world in the chorus almost to its breaking point (âIâll⊠be⊠thereâŠâ) before getting to the songâs title, she makes her move but seems almost nonchalant about doing so, and thus all the more irresistible. Itâs one of the albumâs catchiest, classiest songs, but also atypical top 40 fareâfor instance, what other â94 pop hits featured a luxurious vibraphone solo?
âLike A Motorwayâ is somehow even catchier and further out there. Switching back from live strings to full-on electronica, its lengthy, instrumental intro positions it as a companion piece to âUrban Clearwayââthat is, until Cracknell appears, sighing the songâs main hook (âHeâs goneâ) into an analog synth cavern. What follows is one of the more sublime and enigmatic songs in the bandâs catalog. On the surface, itâs simply another vaguely Latin-accented tale of a former lover, a man who has just left a woman, but sheâs not the singer. While Cracknell empathizes with her, sheâs also observing from a distance. It all feels like an Antonioni film, with lengthy instrumental passages occasionally broken up by such musings as, âShe said her life was like a motorway / dull gray and long, until he came along.â Whereas âHug My Soulâ looked ahead in anticipation, âLike A Motorwayâ stares in the opposite direction, pondering what has occurred, trying to cull meaning from the past.
A departure from previous Saint Etienne releases in that it less resembles a sample-heavy mix tape with bits and pieces of pop culture effluvia serving as the glue holding all of it together, Tiger Bay is more of an actual ten-track song album. Although it eschews samples (mostly for string arrangements), it has three instrumentals (possibly four, depending on whether you isolate âTankervilleâ from the medley it forms with âWestern Windâ), the second of which, âOn The Shoreâ returns to the bandâs original concept of using a series of guest vocalists. Shara Nelson (best known for Massive Attackâs âUnfinished Sympathyâ) lends her soulful wail to a cod-reggae backing track thatâs gently buoyed along by an insistent, two-note staccato filigree and occasional string and oboe interjections. Pretty and pleasant and not at all profound, it works well enough as a breath of fresh air between two far more serious tracks.
âMarble Lionsâ patiently lies in waiting on the other side. At first a return to the whispered elegance of âFormer Loverâ, it builds slowly, but from the onset is far more direct. Cracknell sings, âEverybody wants something and I want it all,â but not in a bratty wayâmore like in awe of the world and all its possibilities. âStars are calling, goodnight, darling; donât say goodbyeâ goes the gentle chorus; with it, Cracknell (who co-wrote the song with Michael Bund) appears to be praying for this special moment to endure for as long as it can. When the full orchestra appears after two minimally arranged verses of isolated electric guitar, flute and oboe, the effect is the same as in âUrban Clearwayâ, everything coming to life at once. Both antidotes to the existential despair of âLike A Motorwayâ, âOn the Shoreâ and âMarble Lionsâ take comfort in the here and now: they are calm oases no matter how brief, as essential to life (or any narrative) as breathing.
The third of the albumâs singles (but the first one to be released), âPale Movieâ is Tiger Bayâs most Euro-sounding track (band member Bob Stanley described as âa pastiche of a Spanish folk songâ), and, with its florid orchestration, on-the-nose flamenco guitar and insistent disco beat, also its most dated song (although it actually pre-dated the whole Ricky Martin/Jennifer Lopez-led Latin pop craze by five years). However, Saint Etienne is one of those rare outfits that excel at being both frothy and cerebral. Itâs not difficult to get swept away by the songâs many effusive charms, from the swirling, effervescent âla, la, laâ chorus to purposely silly lyrics that name-drop American actress Demi Moore and Nepalese mountaineer Sherpa Tenzing.
If any single theme emerges from Tiger Bayâs diverse collection of sounds and tones, itâs the persistence of movement. Although the album title references a singular place (a Welsh port), its ten tracks form a travelogue of sorts, only more of the mind than any specific locale. It doesnât matter exactly where the âUrban Clearwayâ runs or where the âMarble Lionsâ sit or even if âTankervilleâ can be pinpointed on a map; there is even the nagging feeling that not all the album (or possibly any of it) is set in Tiger Bay itself. Instead, each song simply provides an outline for the listener to project his or her own ideas as to what the inhabited landscape is. For example, take âCool Kids of Deathâ, a nearly six-minute long electro-dance instrumental. Its chief hooks are house piano chords, Cracknellâs occasional wordless backing vocals and a six-note melodica riff thatâs almost a variation of the theme song to The Saint. As with any instrumental, thereâs purposely no context apart from the title (and even that was originally meant to be âCool Kiss of Deathâ). Still, the trackâs relentless pace suggests more than just a placeholderâat best, one can imagine some sort of sustained action occurring; whether it involves the titular figures or not is left up to oneâs own imagination.
At least three different versions of Tiger Bay exist. The one surveyed here is the original UK release; a few months later, an American edition (with the band photo on the cover) came out, but with an altered track listing: âHug My Soulâ and âFormer Loverâ swapped places (I actually prefer this sequencing, only because it works and, as an American, it was the first way I heard it) and âWestern Wind/Tankervilleâ was completely obliterated and replaced with âI Was Born On Christmas Dayâ, an even frothier track than âPale Movieâ that was a stand-alone UK single the previous December. Rather inexplicably, the album was re-released in the UK in 1996 with an âamplifiedâ track listing that added on four more songs, including âHeâs On The Phoneâ, their highest charting UK hit (#11), first released in late â95 to accompany the singles collection Too Young To Die.
I didnât hear the original UK version until it was part of the bandâs âdeluxe editionâ two-disc reissue series of their back catalog in 2009-2010. Previously, I considered Tiger Bay as one of Saint Etienneâs lesser albums; hearing it with âWestern Wind/Tankervilleâ intact, the album suddenly, beautifully, fully resonated. A seven-minute, three-part suite, the track opens with âFormer Loverâ-like austerity, Cracknell singing what could be a trad-folk melody (âWestern wind / when will thou blow?â) over mournful acoustic guitarâall nearly resembling something from The Wicker Man soundtrack. Around the one-minute mark, strings begin slowly fading in, along with a burbling electronic undercurrent. Thirty seconds later, you sense a heavy Serge Gainsbourg influence with the arrival of a full orchestra (complete with harp glissando) and a beat that anticipates trip-hop (a genre that will start deeply permeating 100 Albums in a few entries). This is the instrumental âTankervilleâ portion of the song. Unhurriedly flowing like a glass-eyed stream but punctuated by dramatic orchestral flourishes, it continues until the last minute when âWestern Windâ reappears, only in a slightly more foreboding key. What wasnât exactly lighthearted at the beginning ends rather ominously with Cracknell and guest vocalist Stephen Duffy reprising the opening melody and lyrics as the trip-hop beat and orchestration quietly continue, only joined by a faint, siren-like noise.
When preceded by âI Was Born on Christmas Dayâ, âThe Boy Scouts of Americaâ makes precious little sense. However, with âWestern Wind/Tankervilleâ as its lead in, it registers more clearly as part of Tiger Bayâs overall design. A lingering wisp of a song, it depicts a narrative about a boy who âhas to keep guardâ over a girl who âlies in bedâ in a house in Paraguay. We never learn what heâs protecting her from, only that âGod has derailed the Lonestar train / that could take her away from sadness and pain.â Cracknell relays the simplistic melody in her beguiling, childlike voice as the opulent, John Barry-esque orchestration seems less pop song than almost folk murder-ballad designed specifically for the stage or screen. At the final verse, she enigmatically concludes, âThe Boy Scouts of America taught him all that he knows.â The strings linger a bit, and then fade out into the ether. The album closes as effectively and dramatically as it began.
Tiger Bay was such a departure for Saint Etienne that it likely baffled a lot of the bandâs UK fans (the botched American release had nary an impact on their standing in the States.) Like So Tough, it entered the top ten, but plummeted rapidly down the charts. Perhaps in response to this public indifference (and also exhaustion from having recorded three albums in as many years), the band took a four-year sabbatical; weâll catch up with them when they return with their fourth albumâyet another departure, albeit a radically different one from So Tough to Tiger Bay.
Up next: A singular voice seeking no sentimental prisons, no political churches.
(My 100 favorite albums in chronological order:Â #37Â â released March 9, 1993)
Track listing: Mario’s Cafe / Railway Jam / Date With Spelman / Calico / Avenue / You’re In A Bad Way / Memo To Pricey / Hobart Paving / Leafhound / Clock Milk / Conchita Martinez / No Rainbows For Me / Here Come Clown Feet / Junk The Morgue / Chicken SoupÂ
My first year in Boston, the day before Thanksgiving: Iâm braving the chilly air, escaping my box-like Allston apartment to explore the city, my true new home. At Boomerangâs, an AIDS Action charity thrift store (the now long-gone, exceptionally spacious location on Canal Street near North Station), I pick up a cut-out-bin cassette of British trio Saint Etienneâs nearly five-year-old second album, along with a few others (including Prefab SproutâsJordan: The Comeback). Upon leaving the store, I put So Tough into my Sony Walkman, and set off on foot towards the North End.
Before we get to the rest of So Tough, some backstory on Saint Etienne. Most days, I consider them my favorite band (no one else will have more entries in 100 Albums) but they also draw a significant proverbial line in the sand in this projectâs chronology. Until now, every artist Iâve written about has at least one exceptional musical talent warranting their inclusion here, whether as a vocalist, lyricist, pianist, producer, etc.; thatâs not to say Saint Etienne lacks any of those talents (as a singer, Cracknell is on her own distinct plane) but their approach in cultivating them is radically different. The bandâs founders, childhood friends Bob Stanley and Pete Wiggs arenât technically proficient musiciansâneither one can sing or really play a musical instrument. However, both are fervent music fans, the types one imagines having massive record collections encapsulating everything from hit singles to long-forgotten crate digging obscurities (additionally, Stanley is also a music journalist). Craftily making use of the time periodâs newfangled, accessible technology (samplers, drum machines, cheap synthesizers) and studio assistance from engineer/unofficial band member Ian Catt, Stanley and Wiggs took punk and rapâs DIY nature (if not its sound) to heart, proving you could make great pop music if you had the vision (if not necessarily the technique).
Originally conceived as a vehicle with a revolving cast of vocalists (Moira Lambert sings on the bandâs first single, an unrecognizable dance cover of Neil Youngâs âOnly Love Can Break Your Heartâ which, oddly enough, remains their only charting song in the US), Stanley and Wiggs soon found an ideal permanent front-person in Cracknell. She first appears on Saint Etienneâs glorious third single, âNothing Can Stop Usâ which established the bandâs cut-and-paste aesthetic, sounding as if they sampled bits and pieces of a dozen 1960s Dusty Springfield tunes and assembled them into something both familiar and fresh. While UK fans tend to revere the bandâs debut album, Fox Base Alpha (1991), to me itâs a little half-baked apart from the aforementioned singles and a few isolated tracks like the lovely âSpringâ; perhaps you just had to be there in early â90s London to feel and understand what sea change it indicated.
Clocking in at over seven-and-a-half minutes, âAvenueâ is the albumâs centerpiece and not just for its epic length. It kicks off with a quick thud, as if instantly materializing before us. A faint fog of keyboards and Cracknell cooing, âOoo-ooo-ooh⊠your⊠heartâ over and over fades in until the first verse arrives. We hear her sing both the melody (as dictated by the lyrics) and a countermelody of nothing but âbup, bup, baâsâ. The mostly electronic music resembles what would transpire if someone cut up the entirety of Sgt. Pepperâs Lonely Hearts Club Band and spat it back out through a sampler. The chorus reprises the opening melody only to resolve in a thrilling, dramatic chord change where Cracknell urgently wails the line, âAnd, ooooh⊠oh, the clownâs no good,â stretching out âgoodâ to four yearning, mysterious, blissful syllables.
Following âMemo to Priceyâ, a non-sequitur 23-second link (basically a pub conversation backed with music from an ancient Chanel No. 5 advert) and dialogue from obscure 1972 film Made (âDo you think a girl should go to bed with fellaâŠâ) comes âHobart Pavingâ, the albumâs other peak. A simple, sparse ballad, it places Cracknell front-and-center singing an almost impossibly beautiful, fragile melody. Lyrically, the song seems to be about a woman waiting on a train platform, leaving someone or something behind (a lover, a family, a childhood home?), but itâs never as clean-cut as the scenario laid out in, say, The Beatlesâ âSheâs Leaving Homeâ. Instead, Cracknell strings phrases such as âRain falls like Elvisâ tears,â together with song titles (âNo Sugar Tonightâ, âDim all the Lightsâ) and the repeated line in the chorus, âBaby, donât forget to catch me.â While the original UK album version sticks to this minimalist piano-and-voice template (along with a harmonica solo), the single version (which also appears on the albumâs US edition) adds an orchestral arrangement from cult artist/Brian Wilson-collaborator Van Dyke Parks. Combining synthesizers with real instruments, it enhances the song tenfold, adding complexity without obscuring that which made it so affecting in the first place.
âAvenueâ through âHobart Pavingâ is the albumâs most dynamic section, its two bookends illustrating Saint Etienneâs tendency to respectively create entirely new sonic worlds out of artifacts of (and references to) the past and infuse traditional song structures with their own singular outlook. The rest of So Tough pings back and forth between such extremes, as if to say anything is possible where pop music is concerned.
Still, Saint Etienneâs love of pop comes through just as often as their impulse to experiment. âCalicoâ isolates Cracknell to repeatedly, effervescently sighing the title world in the chorus, allowing 16-year-old female rapper Q Tee to take the verses. The latterâs distinct tone (perhaps a Brit equivalent to Digable Planetsâ Ladybug Mecca) unlocks another door in the bandâs universe, while the loping, Middle-Eastern accented melody creates a big enough hook for even the casual listener to hang on to. âLeafhoundâ is a playful whirlwind of Balearic guitar, orchestral synths and Cracknellâs sweet, conversational tone as she revisits a strangely familiar locale. She reminisces in the chorus, âSomething about this place makes me lose a grip on time and space,â phonetically spelling out each syllable as if in awe. The tonal polar opposite of âHobart Pavingâ, “Leafhound” cultivates a sense of return and renewal, with Cracknell concluding, âYes, I know itâs strange / that you could be here with me now,â that last word neatly spiked with exuberance as if sung by the young girl on the album cover (who is actually Cracknell herself).
Haunted Jukebox 